AnyBook4Less.com	Find the Best Price on the Web Order from a Major Online Bookstore
Home  |  Store List  |  FAQ  |  Contact Us  |
Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine Save Your Time And Money Keyword AuthorISBN

Title: Jazz-Rock: A History by Stuart Nicholson ISBN: 0-8256-7188-4 Publisher: Music Sales Corp Pub. Date: 01 May, 1998 Format: Hardcover Volumes: 1 List Price(USD): $29.95

Your Country USA Canada United Kingdom Australia Austria Belgium France Germany Italy Netherlands Switzerland Currency AutoUSD CAD GBP EUR AUD CHF Delivery Only cheapest delivery All delivery options Include Used Books Are you a club member of: Barnes and Noble Books A Million Chapters.Indigo.ca

Average Customer Rating: 3.8 (5 reviews)

Rating: 4
Summary: A good overview.
Comment: It's a shame this book is out of print in the US (I found my copy brand-new in a hole-in-the-wall music store in Berlin), because a study of this particular strain of jazz has been long overdue. Nicholson does a super job of framing the earliest beginnings of jazz-rock in the mid-1960s, when folks such as Jeremy Steig, The Flock and Charles Lloyd were making those links and also making some great music in the bargain. The in-depth chapters on Weather Report, John McLaughlin and Miles Davis (naturally!)come off particularly well ; Nicholson is not one to over-praise his subjects, but his reviews of their work, good and bad, are comprehensive and well-reasoned and he's great at getting their stories from as many sides as possible.

Having said that, I have some quibbles with the book. The distinction Nicholson makes between "jazz-rock" and "fusion" is at best highly debatable and I can't help but wonder if this explains the absence of even a bare mention of certain bands that, to my mind, qualify as playing "jazz-rock" (the most glaring omissions include a lot of UK bands, specifically Brand X, Bill Bruford's Earthworks and Phil Manzanera's Quiet Sun). Like a lot of critics, he can be high-handed in his judgements of certain artists and groups; I particularly disagree with his assessments of Jamaladeen Tacuma and Mike Stern's albums as bandleaders, most of which I think deserved better examinations. But by and large Nicholson suceeds at detailing a particular period within the history of jazz and makes a compelling study that shows that what emerged from the "jazz-rock" period was a lot of music that still thrills!

Rating: 4
Summary: A valid history of an important genre
Comment: This book was a valid history of an important genre. I found it more textbook like than other histories, and was at times somewhat disjointed, and the author tended to make sweeping generalizations about the quality of artistry on various albums; however I found the book to have much useful information in it, and as I have been an avid listener to Jazz, Progressive Rock, and Jazz-rock for many years, I was happy to see that someone had undertaken the task of writing a book with this much detail. At times I found the book to be difficult to read but it was worth the effort. The sad thing about books about music is that the book form is very limited in its ability to make a point. This book would make a good companion textbook in a college course,with accompanying audio and video files, or would possibly be a decent outline for a documentary series on Jazz-Rock.

Rating: 3
Summary: Tells Most of the Story
Comment: Let's say you've read Ted Gioia's History of Jazz or watched Ken Burns and you are wondering about the whole new world of contemporary jazz that gets glossed over in those treatments. You're saying to yourself -- Hey! What about Michael Brecker or Larry Coryell? If that is the case, then this book is your answer. It suffices for a slightly out of date icing on the cake of the great jazz heritage that calls for a modern documentary on the prolific stream of modern jazz (or jazz-rock) from the mid 60's to the end of the 20th century. Specializing in the Electronic Virtuoso era (Mahavishnu, Return to Forever and the like), you will not find a better documentation of the days when there seemed to be no limit to Contemporary jazz or prototype fusion.

No better accounting of the influence Jimi Hendrix had on fusion is available. Whereas Burns and Gioia rightly trace almost everything back to Louis Armstrong, Stuart Nicholson makes a very strong case for Miles Davis' opening of the fusion floodgates.

I rated Nicholson's book with three stars, however, because of some unfortunate editorial biases and pointless rabbit trails. First, Nicholson draws arbitrary lines between what he considers true Jazz Rock and more commercially driven products. We can agree that those distinctions may exist, but we are left without a clear, objective criterion for what passes for the real thing. Bob James, who demonstrates great authentic jazz capability with his "Bob James Trio" release is otherwise relegated to "fuzak" for example. His best treatment of this issue surrounds Stanley Clarke who made strides to become popularized in his later productions in comparison to Clarke's earliest work. Nicholson fails to treat other worthy musicians with the same care and gets very sloppy, resorting to pigeon holes based on labels and sales. Had he been familiar with the industry, he would have mentioned Dave Grusin---while perhaps the foremost "sinner" of popularized smooth jazz---nevertheless made a mark on the jazz world with his legendary ensemble, The GRP All Star Band, not to mention his soundtrack for Three Days of the Condor. Grusin never gets a sentence in the book.

Worst yet, he bases his full opinion of the Yellowjackets on the Marc Russo era with only a mention of Bob Mintzer's membership in the band. Based on the date of his publication, he should have provided extensive analysis of the transformation of the Yellowjackets with Mintzer -- clearly one of the greatest examples of his very thesis! His discussions over the jazz influences on popular rock take him too far a field. A short chapter on some examples could have opened up space for a more thorough treatment of impact artists like David Beniot, Jeff Lorber, Dave Weckl and Brandon Fields.

Besides the overdone ideology, there are several brilliant moments that answer many questions about almost forgotten artists. Despite its flaws, the book is worth the purchase if this era is of interest to you.