Order from a Major Online Bookstore
Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine
Save Your Time And Money
| AnyBook4Less.com | Order from a Major Online Bookstore |
|
| Home | Store List | FAQ | Contact Us | | ||
| Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine Save Your Time And Money |
||
 |
Title: Clone: The Road to Dolly and the Path Ahead by Gina Bari Kolata, Gina Kolata ISBN: 0-688-16634-2 Publisher: Quill Pub. Date: 01 January, 1999 Format: Paperback Volumes: 1 List Price(USD): $14.95 |
Average Customer Rating: 3.4 (5 reviews)
Rating: 1
Summary: One Big Yawn
Comment: As a biochemistry major I was very excited about reading this book. I expected it to have in depth details on cloning and mention true clones such as identical twins. What a disappointment. The book went on and on for numerous pages about the ethical ramifications of cloning (yes, those exact same ethical ramifications TV and newspapers dealt with ad nauseam). Which yes, are important, but not enough to drone on about especially after readers have heard them all 10 times before. I actually found myself sighing and rolling my eyes over some of the ethical stances that were mentioned because they were so silly. I continued reading the book for a while in hopes that it would get better. It didn't. I finally threw the book under my bed (the black hole of bookdom) without ever finishing it.
Rating: 5
Summary: A Tale of Science & Myth on the 'road to Dolly'.
Comment: Looking for an accessible guide to cloning together with sex, scandal, a putative hoax, a fraud claim, counterclaims, industrial secrets and a cast of maverick scientists and myths that makes for a greatly entertaining true story ? To find a single book which has the potential to affect one's ideas and thoughts as to what it means to be human is a rarity, but some readers might be so affected by this work. Thematically weaving between the key historical developments leading to claims for the first cloning success using adult tissue and discussions of the moral ethics of whether and why such research be conducted, Kolata's account of the making of 'Dolly' the sheep reminded me of Watson's 'The Double helix'. Not only do we read here about the manipulation of genetic material outside the realms of human replication and fertility, we are continually provoked with the wider issues relating to food production processess, the social responsibilies of the research scientist, and the role of science journalism in informing public opinion.We are also exposed to the less attractive side of running the day-to-day life of the research laboratory - the struggle with grant competition; peer pressure, review and publication demands; conference attendance and institutional sponsor politics. Kolata provides all of this in a very well written and researched book including frank (and seemingly) honest biographies of the leading players in the 'road to Dolly'. The story as presented here covers a period of just over one hundred years following Weismann's discovery of the 'loss of information' with subsequent cellular differentiations of dividing tissue. Within twenty years or so the role of the cell nucleus had been determined, and by 1938, Spemann's 'Embryonic Development and Induction' proposed the very nuclear transplant experiment that was to succeed some 60 years later. The first successful accounts of this technique involved the use of the embryonic frog tissue in the 1950s by Briggs & King, but the older, more differentiated cell' nuclei proved harder to handle and maintain. In the early 1960s, Gurdon succeeds with the transfer of what were thought to be adult, fully differentiated cells taken from amphibian intestines. At about the same time as these developments were unfolding, the first symposia to address the possibility of cloning and its implications for ethics had taken place. The end of the 1960s had seen the advent of gene isolation (though curiously little is said about the discovery of DNA itself and the significance of the newly founded growth area of molecular biology) and within the next ten years we had moved from the in vitro fertilisation of mice to Louise Brown, born in 1978. That same year saw the publication of a non-fiction book claiming that the real-life 'rich, eccentric Max' has himself cloned with the assistance of a World renown scientist known by the pseudonym 'Darwin' with the assistance of a seventeen year old virgin called 'sparrow', who gives birth to a healthy baby boy. I would recommend reading Kolata for her retelling of the Rorvik (1978) story if for no other reason. The following year saw Illmensee claim to have cloned the first mice using the nucleus of embryonic stem cells and, again, we are both entertained and informed by Kolata's telling of this most remarkable tale of intrigue and collegiate suspicion of happenings in the laboratory. It was not until the 1980s` and 90s that successful sheep, cow and eventually monkey cloning was to be completed (all still using embryonic nuclear material transfer) at least suggesting that there was no in principle reason to believe adult cloning to be beyond possibility. However, very few scientists apparently held this latter belief - and these few were not encouraged to pursue their ideas. Now suitably brought up to speed with our history of embryology, experimental biology techniques and the sweat involved in conducting seemingly unglamorous basic laboratory science, we are finally introduced to Ian Wilmut, whose research group were to achieve what to many was still 'biologically impossible'. Wilmut and his colleage Campbell postulated that the problem of cloning transplants was perhaps with tranfering the nuclear DNA at such a time inappropriate to the natural activity phases of the cell cycle. Campbell determined that the so colled G0 (G-nought) phase of the cell cycle was one of synchrony and, combined with the technique of halting induced by nutritional deprivation, thought that it was during this period that cell 'reprogramming' would be more likely successful. In March, 1996 the first clones of a mammal (sheep) were born using differentiated embryonic cell nuclei, but their announcement was largely lost to the wider world outside that of a handful of agricultural scientists. However, in July of the same year, the first sheep cloned from the fully-differentiated cell nuclei of adult tissue was born to Wilmut's lab. However, the news that was to reach the world over had first to wait out a period of great secrecy and gossip-mongering. The (true) story is revealed lucidly here, and provides another reason to read Kolata's book. And yes, in this account she was named for Dolly Parton.
Rating: 3
Summary: Interesting but too sensationalistic
Comment: Clone: The Road to Dolly... is an interesting book outlining the research that contributed to the creation of the first mammalian clone and its philosophical implications.
There is much in the book to recommend it. It places the work in its correct historical context by describing the chain of discoveries, beginning with those in the early part of this century, that eventually led to Dolly.
However, the book is needlessly sensationalistic in the way it describes science and scientists, seeming to draw parallels with the worlds of power politics and showbiz. Science is really a more subdued and low-key affair - as exemplified by the very lab that created Dolly.
My major objection is that the book appears to take as its underlying assumption that the public (or a large segment) is opposed to science and treats its acheivements with profound suspicion. I agree that there exists a vocal minority that thinks this way and may have its roots in various fundamentalist movements. However, the majority of people that I have met, while frequently poorly informed, are not antagonistic to science, but rather are interested in enjoying the fruits of its labor. This may be why, as the book says, while various self-styled experts debate the ethics of cloning, infertile couples are lining up for possible medical applications. It is only when the public is either denied the benefits of science, or is not educated about what these benefits may be, that it grows resentful. This issue seems to have been overlooked. On the other hand, comparisons with the atomic bomb are abundant, though meaningless. The bomb has killed thousands and was created for that express purpose. Cloning has created very little and destroyed nothing, except a few egos.
Fortuneately, although the book begins grimly, it seems to end on a fairly optimistic note, moving away from its opening notions that cloning is an evil, dirty business.
The bottom line is that whatever else it may do, cloning does not undermine human dignity. A person's dignity arises from his or her actions, not whether they were born as a twin, testtube baby or clone. We would do well to remember that. To my mind, the most profound line in this book full of lines that compete for that honor is one attributed to a Scottish farmer who says, in some perplexity, 'I don't understand the big deal. A sheep is still a sheep.'
 |
Title: Cloning: For and Against by M. L. Rantala, Arthur J., Phd. Milgram ISBN: 0812693752 Publisher: Open Court Publishing Company Pub. Date: 01 December, 1998 List Price(USD): $19.95 |
 |
Title: Understanding Cloning by Sandy Fritz, Scientific American ISBN: 0446678740 Publisher: Warner Books Pub. Date: 01 March, 2002 List Price(USD): $11.95 |
 |
Title: The Second Creation: Dolly and the Age of Biological Control by Ian Wilmut, Keith Campbell, Colin Tudge ISBN: 0674005864 Publisher: Harvard University Press Pub. Date: 01 July, 2001 List Price(USD): $16.95 |
 |
Title: Who's Afraid of Human Cloning? by Gregory E. Pence ISBN: 0847687821 Publisher: Rowman & Littlefield Publishers Pub. Date: 01 January, 1998 List Price(USD): $14.95 |
 |
Title: Remaking Eden by Lee Silver ISBN: 0380792435 Publisher: Perennial Pub. Date: 01 October, 1998 List Price(USD): $14.95 |
Thank you for visiting www.AnyBook4Less.com and enjoy your savings!
Copyright� 2001-2021 Send your comments
