Order from a Major Online Bookstore
Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine
Save Your Time And Money
| AnyBook4Less.com | Order from a Major Online Bookstore |
|
| Home | Store List | FAQ | Contact Us | | ||
| Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine Save Your Time And Money |
||
 |
Title: Guderian: Panzer General by Kenneth MacKsey ISBN: 1-85367-538-5 Publisher: Greenhill Books/Lionel Leventhal Pub. Date: March, 2003 Format: Hardcover Volumes: 1 List Price(USD): $34.95 |
Average Customer Rating: 3.67 (3 reviews)
Rating: 1
Summary: Unrevised from an unsatisfactory first edition
Comment: Sadly, Kenneth Macksey has declined to perform the major revision that the publisher trumpets on the dustcover. It is not "revised and fully updated" nor can one certify that it "draws upon fresh source material." Macksey retired from the Royal Tank Regiment in the 1950s and has since become a prolific writer on all matter of things military. He frequently provides interesting details in his books that cannot be found elsewhere but few source materials to guide the reader further. By now, he must be recognized as a 'pop' writer of history, drawing upon his past works to flesh out new themes and narratives. As interesting as the story of Heinz Guderian is, the author has embellished and exaggerated his story, already well promoted by Guderian himself, and added a fawning, gushy style that convinces me that he has lapsed into a sheer hagiography of a man he admires without limit.
Macksey reveals much when he styles Guderian in the same class as British tank pioneers such as J.F.C. Fuller and Percy Hobart. Scholarship of the last 20 years has fairly demolished their reputations and their former icon status. But Macksey is at ease more with the interpretations and source material of the 1950s. Indeed, his "revision" introduces only two new sources, the story of the cracking of the German 'Enigma' codes by the British, revealed by F.H. Hinsley and others in the 1970s, and the publication, in German, of a biography of Erich Fellgiebel, who Macksey considers a key signal officer of the Wehrmacht (and ample material for yet another of his books). The sole source in Macksey's 1 ½ page bibliography postdating his first edition is a volume of Hinsley (1979) and Macksey makes little use of the Enigma story in any case.
The book reveals a strange, iconoclastic and chatty writing style, utterly fawning over Guderian and his record, invoking badly skewed historical presentation and logic in almost every page, such that it remains a maddening read. Macksey relies far too much on Guderian's memoir, Panzer Leader (1953), offers a few letters between Guderian and his wife as the fruit of the "extensive Guderian family archives." The rest of his sources are near-obsolete ones, like John Wheeler-Bennett's 1953 Nemesis of Power. He has thus ignored later seminal writing on General Hans von Seekt, the development of the Blitzkrieg doctrine and forces, the command structure, fresh biographies, the conduct of the war and Wehrmacht implication in atrocities, among many relevant topics.
In order to advance the reputation of Guderian, fellow tanker Macksey portrays him as a lone visionary, scarcely understood in his pure and just quest for a dominant tank arm for the German Army. In doing so, Macksey ignores the evident accomplishments of many other thinkers and practitioners in the German forces, from the 1920-26 chief of staff Seekt onward, and ignores character traits of Guderian that show him to be stubborn, impatient and prone to seeing enemies at every obstacle. Not content with the conventional judgement that Guderian was one of Germany's leading armor advocates (nor was Guderian thus content), Macksey makes him the only theorist and visionary and the only able commander of armoured troops. We have no basis of comparison, for lack of knowledge, of the other major leaders of the Panzertruppen (such as Hoth, Kleist, Hoeppner), nor does Macksey explain how infantry officers like Rommel and Manstein could be at least as adept in handling armoured formations as Guderian. He does not indicate to the reader what the various inspectorates of motorized and fast troops did between his departure from them in 1935 and his return as Inspector of Panzer Troops in March, 1943; and they in fact directed most of the design, construction, organization and fielding of the German mechanized forces largely without Guderian's participation.
Guderian surely deserves recognition for his many feats and accomplishments, but with a critical eye of a modern biographer. Macksey cannot supply us with the information we want to know. Instead we have a flawed survey of the German Army, with Guderian pictured as the rebel at its center. I gather that he reads little German, based upon the assistance he acknowledges, and that plays some role in his neglect of sources. But he also invokes the term 'academic' as a pejorative, as in "...the evidence is academic and too thin to be persuasive [p198n]." So Macksey has little use for the tools of modern research and gives us his gut instincts, based upon what he has read. This does not cut it, especially when as a tank officer he writes of a tank pioneer. Why do we know nothing about Guderian's command of one of the first three panzer divisions in 1935-38 (and who were the other two commanders)? Why do we learn little more about the man than he himself wrote in 1953? We learn that he loved his family and enjoyed pastoral scenery! What exactly were his theories in the early years and how are they distinguished from the others working in the field? Guderian was one of the few motor transport officers of the 1920s and combined with his signals experience of World War I, he surely imparted technical improvements to the evolution of the mechanized forces, but can we be so sure of the tactical elements? We simply do not know from this book, but are assured by the author that Guderian was the leader and the brains of the operation of the inspectorate of motorized troops, and (1931-35). To be present at the creation does not make one the architect.
Sadly, this review must lament what might have been instead of extolling the virtues of what has been written. Let this serve as a warning to all of us that the bookshelves offer a broad mix of quality and the reader must discern what truly merits his or her attention.
Rating: 5
Summary: The originator of modern warfare as a man
Comment: This is one of the best military biographies I have read. It gives a very clear picture of Guderian as a surprising sympathetic character with much humanity; whilst at the same time deliniating Guderian's role in defining the nature of modern warfare. It only fails in not bringing Guderian to the public's eye to a position far above Irwin Rommel, a man who accomplishments pale into insignificance by comparison. Macksey makes clear the manner in which Guderian distillated the ideas of Fuller and his Tank Corps contemporaries: the true pioneers of Armoured warfare, and formed them into a practical and workable whole which secured for Germany her early victories and produced a formula for war still employed today as evinced by the Gulf War. In addition his not inconsiderable operational contribution to those victories are clearly explained as was his unique relationship to Hitler, who in marked contrast as to his attitude towards Guderians contemporaries maintained a respectful, if not admirable mein towards Guderian to the very end. A book that should be read by every student of armoured warfare and the Second World War.
Rating: 5
Summary: In-depth study of one good general and theorist
Comment: Whenever we read history books, we encounter a lot of people such as generals, commanders, ministers and presidents. And we begin to have irresistable longing for the knowledge of him or her,especially you find the most interesting people. Guderian was that kind of person I desperately wanted to know. It may be a little difficult for those who are first comers to the military world. But, if you have a little knowlede, you will find this book's benefits. Especially, it is important to me that his career of wireless communication eventually helped him building the modern tank warfare theory. In short conversation, whenever I refer to tank warfare and Guderian's accomplishments, others are caught in fresh shock. They just heard about Rommel whose career in WW¥° was infantry. And another thing which I learnd is that the great accomplishment is not build just in a day. This book will help you find the answer.
 |
Title: Panzer Leader by Heinz Guderian, Kenneth Macksey, B. H. Liddell Hart, Constatine Fitzgibbon, General Heinz Guderian ISBN: 0306811014 Publisher: DaCapo Press Pub. Date: 24 December, 2001 List Price(USD): $18.95 |
 |
Title: Achtung - Panzer! (Cassell Military Classics) by Heinz Guderian ISBN: 0304352853 Publisher: Sterling Publishing Pub. Date: 30 June, 2000 List Price(USD): $9.95 |
 |
Title: The Rommel Papers (Da Capo Paperback) by Erwin Rommel, B. H. Liddell-Hart, Basil Henry Liddell Hart, Liddell Basil Henry Hart ISBN: 0306801574 Publisher: DaCapo Press Pub. Date: April, 1988 List Price(USD): $22.00 |
 |
Title: Rommel and His Art of War (Greenhill Military Paperbacks.) by Erwin Rommel, John Pimlott ISBN: 1853675431 Publisher: Greenhill Books/Lionel Leventhal Pub. Date: March, 2003 List Price(USD): $19.95 |
 |
Title: Tigers in the Mud: The Combat Career of German Panzer Commander Otto Carius (Stackpole Military History Series) by Otto Carius, Robert J. Edwards ISBN: 0811729117 Publisher: Stackpole Books Pub. Date: September, 2003 List Price(USD): $19.95 |
Thank you for visiting www.AnyBook4Less.com and enjoy your savings!
Copyright� 2001-2021 Send your comments
