Order from a Major Online Bookstore
Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine
Save Your Time And Money
| AnyBook4Less.com | Order from a Major Online Bookstore |
|
| Home | Store List | FAQ | Contact Us | | ||
| Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine Save Your Time And Money |
||
 |
Title: Old Testament Commentary Survey by Tremper, III Longman ISBN: 0-8010-2629-6 Publisher: Baker Book House Pub. Date: September, 2003 Format: Paperback Volumes: 1 List Price(USD): $12.99 |
Average Customer Rating: 3 (9 reviews)
Rating: 5
Summary: Worth the wait
Comment: It is a great joy to finally have available the third edition of Tremper Longman's fine review of Old Testament commentaries. It has been a long wait since the 1995 second edition.
Again Longman offers judicious and careful advice on the merits and demerits of a large number of OT commentaries. As with all such comments on the commentaries, there is subjectivism at work, and not all will agree with all of Longman's assessments. After all, how can one say what is the best commentary on, say, Deuteronomy? It really depends on the needs of the reader. A busy pastor may want something more expository and devotional, while the academic may prefer the more technical and scholarly.
Thus Longman tries to rate the commentaries by what they set out to do, or what the series they are contained in set out to do. Thus he comes up with recommendations that may differ from others. For example, of the 19 commentaries on 1 and 2 Kings, he gives the highest rating (5 stars) to Iain Provan's volume in the NIBC series. While acknowledging that it is a bit too brief (in keeping with the series), he believes that in terms of accessibility and readability, along with a good balance of literary and theological emphases, this is the best thing going on Kings.
Interestingly, David Bauer, in his An Annotated Guide to Biblical Resources for Ministry (Hendrickson, 2003), does not even give Provan's volume a mention, in the 21 books he lists. However, John Glynn in his Commentary and Reference Survey, 9th ed. (Kregel, 2003), does mention it, along with 16 other commentaries.
Thus there will always be disagreements in this area, as a lot of differing criteria and measuring sticks are used to make assessments.
One omission from this volume is the section on OT reference works and Hebrew helps. They too, like the commentaries, continue to pour forth at an alarming rate. Thus cuts need to be made somewhere.
But of the three reference works cited here (the other two cover the NT as well), Longman is my first port of call. Unlike the other two authors, Longman is an OT specialist, with several fine commentaries of his own.
Longman mentions in his intro that many people emailed him, urging him to get a revised edition of this work out. I was one of them, and such lobbying has paid off. One hopes to see a 4th edition before another 8 years lapse however!
Rating: 4
Summary: INDISPENSIBLE, BUT FLAWED
Comment: The positives -- this book is a MUST for anybody at all serious about commentaries. Longman is VERY sharp. A Yale Ph.D. with years of teaching experience, he knows his stuff. Great authroity. Very, very good resource.
The negatives -- this third edition is not what it could be.
Omissions are plentiful. How could he possibly exclude reviews of Dale Ralph Davis' commnetaries on Joshua, Judges, I and 2 Samuel and I Kings? These are some of the best commentaries I've ever used. Another example, how could he leave out O. Palmer Robertson on Jonah?
Also, he often does not clue the reader in on the ideological biases of some works. P. 23 doesn't mention that the Daily Study Bible series is highly critical. Same for p. 58 and Kath. Sakenfeld (far left).
Other puzzles -- how can a book on p. 20 be a "fine" commentary when he gives it just 2 stars (overall he is a very generous grader!).
Some are P&R publishers' editing flaws. How can Longman mention in vol. 1 of a set that the author for vol. 2 is "announced" for the future to be.... when vol. 2 is already out and reviewed by Longman? (see p. 100). Also, some abbreviations used don't appear in the Abbreviation Key ("MT" on p. 107). In three places Longman reviews his own books in the first person ("I was trying to do this..."), whereas for another of his books he refers to himself in the third person as "Longman" (see p. 89). On p. 128 he says it would be "inappropriate" for him to comment on his own book (no way!), but he does this anyway in four other cases.
Overall, excellent book. But it needs better editing, and the addition of some outstanding works that are ignored. (He could easilly cut some things, if need be, that are highly dated, and irrelevant.)
Rating: 1
Summary: Falls uncomfortably between two stools
Comment: The last two reviews accused Dr Longman of being biased and of not being biased enough. The unwary reader might conclude that the author is a fair-minded man who has steered his way between extremes. This is not the case - it is no doubt what he has tried to do, but he has failed. Thus this book has no obvious audience. It will not please those seeking to find books that reliably endorse an evangelical viewpoint, because he includes many books that don't but often fails to tell people that they don't. It will certainly be no good for say Catholics or Jews, or those interested in a Catholic or Jewish viewpoint, because many good books in these categories are not even mentioned. Finally, it will positively mislead anyone looking for books suitable for relative newcomers, because many such books are wrongly labelled "for scholars only", apparently on the sole grounds that they are moderately "critical". This book compares very unfavourably with its predecessor by John Goldingay, alas now unobtainable.
 |
Title: Commentary and Reference Survey: A Comprehensive Guide to Biblical and Theological Resources by John Glynn ISBN: 0825427363 Publisher: Kregel Publications Pub. Date: August, 2003 List Price(USD): $18.99 |
 |
Title: New Testament Commentary Survey by D. A. Carson ISBN: 0801022878 Publisher: Baker Book House Pub. Date: January, 2002 List Price(USD): $12.99 |
 |
Title: A Biblical History of Israel by Iain W. Provan, V. Philips Long, Tremper, Iii Longman, Philips V. Long ISBN: 0664220908 Publisher: Westminster John Knox Press Pub. Date: September, 2003 List Price(USD): $24.95 |
 |
Title: An Annotated Guide to Biblical Resources for Ministry by David R. Bauer ISBN: 1565637232 Publisher: Hendrickson Publishers, Inc. Pub. Date: March, 2003 List Price(USD): $16.95 |
 |
Title: On the Reliability of the Old Testament by K. A. Kitchen ISBN: 0802849601 Publisher: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co. Pub. Date: December, 2003 List Price(USD): $45.00 |
Thank you for visiting www.AnyBook4Less.com and enjoy your savings!
Copyright� 2001-2021 Send your comments
