Order from a Major Online Bookstore
Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine
Save Your Time And Money
| AnyBook4Less.com | Order from a Major Online Bookstore |
|
| Home | Store List | FAQ | Contact Us | | ||
| Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine Save Your Time And Money |
||
 |
Title: Diplomacy by Henry Kissinger ISBN: 0-671-51099-1 Publisher: Simon & Schuster Pub. Date: 04 April, 1995 Format: Paperback Volumes: 1 List Price(USD): $22.00 |
Average Customer Rating: 4.49 (69 reviews)
Rating: 5
Summary: The Origins of American Diplomacy
Comment: Diplomacy by Henry Kissinger
Simon and Schuster, 1994
912 pages.
In his capacity as both the National Security Advisor and as the Secretary of State for two different presidents Henry Kissinger redefined the nature and scope of American diplomacy. He served in the most tumultuous administration of the twentieth century yet managed to invigorate foreign policy in what was also the nadir of executive prestige. With Richard Nixon he formulated a grand strategy based on the twin principles of Wilsonian idealism and European realpolitik that led to a period of geopolitical stability in the midst of America's extrication from the Vietnam quagmire. The Nixon-Kissinger team reshaped the nature of Soviet-American relations and introduced a period of détente using triangular diplomacy and the concept of linkage. As both an academic and as a practitioner of the art, Kissinger describes in his book the evolution and philosophical heritage of American diplomacy and its impact on global and regional stability during its rapid ascendancy as a superpower in the twentieth century. Kissinger provides both the casual reader and the foreign policy maven a refreshing history of American foreign policy as a reflection of its uniquely benign belief in its own exceptionalism.
In Diplomacy Kissinger lists two primary schools of thought that govern the conduct and define the characteristics of foreign policy. European diplomacy in its current form traces its roots to Cardinal Richelieu and the primacy of the state. Raison d'etat radically altered international relations because it provided the philosophical justification towards the secularization of national interest. No longer under the suffocating aegis of the church, nations shrugged off idealistic endeavors in favor of policies that provided tangible benefits. The Treaty of Westphalia introduced the modern state system and ushered in a tumultuous period due to the lack of a confluence of common interests and a shared system of values in the concert of nations. Following the chaos of the Napoleonic Wars Metternich presided over a period of relative stability in Europe by positioning the decaying Austrian Empire as the fulcrum of the European balance of power. In his relentless pursuit towards the creation of a unified Germany, Bismarck dispensed with incremental gains and boldly asserted Prussian hegemony with a series of wars buttressed by peace settlements that consolidated his gains. Bismarck unhinged the Vienna settlement and dealt the existing balance a mortal blow. The cold calculus of raw power supplanted the Metternich consensus of legitimacy and in the wake of the entangling system of alliances that ensued, a European conflagration became almost inevitable. Indeed the singular practice of realpolitik, Kissinger asserts, "turned on itself" .
Whereas realpolitik was distilled from the crucible of armed conflict, Wilsonian idealism reflected the triumphs of democracy and manifest destiny, together with the unshakeable belief in the exportability of the uniquely American system of values. While Kissinger lauds the style and substance of American diplomacy he nonetheless insists on the exercise of restraint governed by the realization of American national interest. According to Kissinger the most successful American statesmen were those capable of blending Wilsonian idealism with realpolitik. While Wilson provided the conceptual basis for American foreign policy in its ascendancy as a great power, he was unable to realize his objectives. A generation later, Roosevelt, borrowing heavily from Wilson's Fourteen Points, co-authored the Atlantic Charter and provided the framework for the United Nations. Roosevelt was successful because he possessed a surer grasp of the tenor of national consensus. He advanced Wilson's idealism and accepted the responsibilities of great power status yet accepted the territorial aggrandizement of the Soviet Union. The nation that implemented the Marshall Plan and sponsored the economic recovery of its former enemies was the same nation that unleashed weapons of unprecedented destructiveness on Nagasaki and Hiroshima.
Kissinger's analysis of American diplomacy during the Cold War is particularly noteworthy. From the prescient George Kennan to the equally remarkable Ronald Reagan, Kissinger chronicles the evolution of American strategies of containment. As a statesman he refrains from the insensitive criticism of an academic, and as an academic he bases his analysis on research rather than a political or personal agenda. Kissinger traces the theoretical origins of Cold War diplomacy in the Truman administration through its first tests in Greece and Turkey and armed intervention in Korea. He clarifies the persisting debate on Vietnam and rather than vilifying a single administration as is the popular pastime of many historians, he traces the efforts of four separate presidents and nearly twenty years of American involvement. It is remarkable, however, that Kissinger merely brushes over an event as significant as the Cuban missile crisis.
Although Kissinger devotes the majority of his book to American diplomacy, he evaluates the actions of both allies and adversaries and their respective impact on the geopolitical environment. He supports Kennan's thesis that the collapse of the Soviet Union was inevitable but credits American diplomacy with limiting Soviet aggression and containing communist infiltration in regions vital to American interests.
American diplomacy, Kissinger asserts, is the product of American exceptionalism and democratic necessity. Lacking the unifying force of an opposing superpower, the United States may again fall victim to the siren song of isolationism. Kissinger devotes the final pages of his book to a call for the development of a national interest. National interest will undoubtedly combine elements of realpolitik and Wilsonian idealism and define limits in order to prevent the exhaustion of American will and an overextension of American capabilities. National interest will also provide the requisites for unilateral action in a world increasingly suspicious of the military, economic, and cultural domination of the sole superpower. The current outlook is not auspicious. Western Europe, for the most part a steadfast ally during the Cold War, is breaking ranks and currently one of the most vociferous critics of American foreign policy. Future administrations face new challenges in an increasingly complicated new world order where simple geopolitical calculations are rendered useless and threats to American security span continents in the form of decentralized terrorist cells. However, America has answered challenges to the Wilsonian goals of peace, stability, progress, and freedom for mankind with resolve and moral conviction in the twentieth century. And though it may be a "journey that has no end," Kissinger's faith in the purpose and goals of American diplomacy remains unshakable.
Rating: 5
Summary: In America's Self-Interest
Comment: Kissinger's Diplomacy sets two themes. First Kissinger describes how the modern nation state emerged from the Treaty of Westphalia in 1648, where nations (at the time only European) agreed to stay out of each other's internal affairs; he continues with an excellent, though obviously partisan, history of Europe's great diplomats, from Richelieu to Bismark. He segues from 19th century European to 20th century American diplomacy, concentrating on Teddy Roosevelt, Woodrow Wilson, and of course Richard Nixon and himself. Following through, he brings to center stage his second theme: motives. Why do countries do what they do, and in particular why America does what it does.
The treaty of Westphalia set the stage for all modern history, up to an including what goes on today. When Russia tells other nations to stay out of Chechnya, it invokes the principles of domestic sovereignty as laid out by Westphalia. When China claims other nations have no say in how it treats dissidents, it again implicitly invokes Westphalia.
Kissinger takes his history of diplomacy from Richelieu to Bismarck, always stressing how practical these men were, and how successful diplomats always put necessity ahead of principles. Realpolitk rules. But what of America? Kissinger presents 20th century foreign policy as a conflict. On one side we find European style diplomacy ruled by principles of geopolitical self-interest; on the other side we find democracy and idealism. Kissinger himself is at a loss.
He obviously follows the European school, and doesnft really understand the American school, but he understands this limitation. Among American presidents, he admires Theodore Roosevelt and Nixon most for their grasp of European-style foreign policy, but strangely it is Ronald Reagan whom he lionizes as some sort of diplomatic genius. Kissinger does not consider Reagan intelligent, but he sees that Reagan won the cold war against the Soviets by diplomatic means, with no direct confrontation. And he doesnft really understand how it was done. Nevertheless, Kissinger still makes a strong case for adopting geopolitical interests as the central value in establish American foreign policy.
For this reason, it remains a topical and important book. Americans are very uncomfortable with going to war for national interests. Now, at the start of the Iraq war, even its supporters squirm when they hear opposing slogans like "No Blood for Oil". Americans prefer standing on principles such as bringing democracy and foiling dictatorships. Kissinger argues this view is misguided, usually, and that it is right for nations to fight simply for their own interests, especially where security is concerned.
Rating: 5
Summary: A Work of Genius
Comment: I'm a history buff and this is one of the most brilliant books I've ever read in terms of its insight and breadth and depth of learning. The main reason it's so good is because of the dazzlingly brilliant light it sheds on the crucial events and phenomena of the modern historical era. Kissinger doesn't just tell you what happened, he tells you why it happened in such a way to open up your eyes to new dimensions for appreciating what James Joyce called the "nightmare" of history. In short, DIPLOMACY isn't just a book; it's an education. It's not often that I've felt so intellectually rewarded after reading a book (though Richard Rhodes' THE MAKING OF THE ATOMIC BOMB, which I'm reading right now, is undoubtedly going to be another one).
From a publishing standpoint, DIPLOMACY has had a rather paradoxical time of it. On one hand, if it was written by an anonymous academic rather than Kissinger, it wouldn't have had anywhere close to the audience it's had, but would then have been treated more fairly by the critics. On the other hand, because it was written by a massively controversial public figure, it's often been panned for political reasons rather than objective critical ones. However, I would implore the common reader that however he or she may happen to feel about Kissinger as a man, don't make the same mistake some of his misguided critics have made. Read the thing with an open mind, and you might just realize you've discovered a true political classic.
 |
Title: Does America Need a Foreign Policy? : Toward a Diplomacy for the 21st Century by Henry Kissinger ISBN: 0684855682 Publisher: Simon & Schuster Pub. Date: 04 September, 2002 List Price(USD): $15.00 |
 |
Title: The Rise and Fall of the Great Powers by Paul Kennedy ISBN: 0679720197 Publisher: Vintage Pub. Date: 15 January, 1989 List Price(USD): $17.00 |
 |
Title: The CLASH OF CIVILIZATIONS AND THE REMAKING OF WORLD ORDER by Samuel P. Huntington ISBN: 0684844419 Publisher: Touchstone Books Pub. Date: 28 January, 1998 List Price(USD): $15.00 |
 |
Title: The Paradox of American Power: Why the World's Only Superpower Can't Go It Alone by Joseph S. Nye Jr. ISBN: 0195150880 Publisher: Oxford University Press Pub. Date: January, 2002 List Price(USD): $28.00 |
 |
Title: YEARS OF RENEWAL by Henry Kissinger ISBN: 0684855720 Publisher: Touchstone Books Pub. Date: 22 March, 2000 List Price(USD): $24.00 |
Thank you for visiting www.AnyBook4Less.com and enjoy your savings!
Copyright� 2001-2021 Send your comments
