Order from a Major Online Bookstore
Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine
Save Your Time And Money
| AnyBook4Less.com | Order from a Major Online Bookstore |
|
| Home | Store List | FAQ | Contact Us | | ||
| Ultimate Book Price Comparison Engine Save Your Time And Money |
||
 |
Title: On Certainty by Ludwig Wittgenstein ISBN: 0-06-131686-5 Publisher: Perennial Pub. Date: 06 October, 1972 Format: Paperback Volumes: 1 List Price(USD): $14.00 |
Average Customer Rating: 4.7 (10 reviews)
Rating: 4
Summary: A Very Useful Little Book from a Very Big Philosopher
Comment: A compilation of loosely connected, aphoristic-like statements about the idea of certainty, taking off from G. E. Moore's famous assertion in favour of common sense, Wittgenstein here presents his thoughts, at the end of his life, concerning the question of how sure of anything we can ever be. Dealing with a fundamentally epistemological question, this little book follows the path Wittgenstein had defined for himself in the latter part of his career, concerning itself with language and how we talk about the ideas we have.
Some misread him very badly, which is not surprising given his penchant for cryptic brevity and his own tendency to avoid extensive explication of his ideas in favour of the brief observation or statement reflecting moments of insight. Indeed, insight seems to have been at the very core of his later philosophy . . . it's all about seeing things in a new way.
On the matter of certainty, his claims here, sometimes rambling and seemingly unconnected, seem to boil down to a couple of points, consistent with his general way of seeing things:
1) Being certain of anything, he seems to say, is a matter of what we mean in the context in which we are expressing certainty. That is, he suggests that "certainty" the word has different meanings, depending on the application, and that we can become too readily confused if we try to apply one meaning (or use) in a place where another is required. As a corollary of this, he clearly holds that there is no basic idea of "certainty" to which all can be reduced, but only a range of related uses of the word in our language. This is in keeping with his larger view of the world as "contained" in our knowledge of it, and our knowledge "contained" in the words we use which are, themselves, a function of our language, which last is a part of our behavioural continuum, representing a rule-governed activity in which we are embedded as what he called a "form of life". (There are significant metaphysical implications for this but he does not touch on these, either in this book or more generally elsewhere, since he felt that to do that was often to stray out of the bounds that language made for us.)
2) As an outgrowth of the above, his second insight here tells us that there are some things of which we can be certain in a way that does not require what we would normally expect, i.e., evidence or proof. That is, sometimes a statement is just grounded in the rules of the game itself, i.e., in order to play in the game we must just assert the certainty . . . and believe in it. While such assertions may look the same as assertions of empirical certainty ("there is a bird outside my window") they are not (e.g., "there is an external world," "there are other minds inside other human bodies," etc.). To doubt certain things like this would be to break the rules of the game in which we are operating, in which case everything else collapses and we can no longer play.
In keeping with his usual approach, Wittgenstein does not present an argument for any of this or even make these claims, quite as explicitly as I have just done, in this book but, rather, confines himself to musings and observations, examples and questions. But it is to these two main points that everything he is presenting in On Certainty leads.
A note: some seem to have concluded from Wittgenstein's penchant for aphorisms and indirection that he was saying things quite different than he really was saying. I note someone here who accuses Wittgenstein of solipsism and this is a woeful misreading of him. His philosophical approach, in fact, put paid to the solipsist argument if read aright! Others have thought he was just playing with words or posturing as some kind of faux mystic. I would suggest that such ideas are false but that they arise because he was so unwilling to explicate his thoughts in the usual discursive way and, perhaps because he thought to do that would just lead one in circles.
So when reading Wittgenstein, you have to do it as he thought it and join him in the gnawing of the intellectual bones he displays in his observations. It is a matter of our seeing his point and not of his establishing logically defensible claims and arguments which we can debate with him or ourselves.
Someone else here likened him to a Zen master and I would suggest that that is very apt, indeed. Although his philosophical interests were mainly epistemological and not "spiritual" (defined as trying to place the conscious self in relation to the world in which it finds itself a la Zen), his techniques were not much different from those of Zen and his outcomes, insights into what we really mean when we say things, were on a par with the Zen idea of achieving satori (the moment of enlightenment). Different focal points, indeed, but the same strategy and the same basic understanding of the way introspective knowledge is secured for both.
Still, this particular work is very incomplete, perhaps because he wrote it while ill and apparently died before he could "complete" it . . . . leaving us a very limited look at a very significant epistemological problem with a somewhat spotty analysis and "solution." The Philosophical Investigations, his last (and also incomplete) work written specifically for publication, has much more to offer on his overall view of things and relative to the basic insights he invokes here in understanding "certainty".
SWM
Rating: 5
Summary: Zen master for the 21st century...
Comment: Wittgenstein hastily wrote "On Certainty" in his last days - several places he seemed frustrated that he was unlikely to be able to get his ideas across. However, this work distills most of his work on the foundations of knowledge in a manner that is quite accessible. In fact, this book should have been entitled something like "cutting through centuries of misguided notions" - you only get clarity of vision such as contained in this volume if you are lucky enough to get samadhi from "show me your original face".
Wittgenstein used Moore's (in)famous paper that started with "knowing" his hand and then deduced the universe. Wittgenstein showed the inherent fallacy of this attempt and in the process paraded the naked emperor of metaphysics around in all its dualistic glory. For Wittgenstein really attacked the 'mapping' of what is really psychology into the analytic framework of philosophy.
Wittgenstein pointed out that doubt is a 'game', in the sense that doubting must follow logical rules. The game runs aground when it attempts to doubt the actual framework - such as doubting your own existence. This is no longer part of the 'game' but instead is simply nonsense or, better, psychology.
Wittgenstein wrote the book in his familiar style utilizing short semi-paragraphs to map out his arguments. I find the format quite similar to Eastern philosophy such as Tao Te Ching and the Zen koans and feel it is quite readable. Other people may want to buy Avrum Stroll's excellent "Moore and Wittgenstein on Certainty" for a more 'standard' overview of the argments.
This is essential reading for anyone interested in the future of philosophy.
Rating: 5
Summary: So damn right, it ought to bleed
Comment: If you want to read a book by Wittgenstein, just so you can say you have read him, or because you feel the need for some direct intellectual contact with a leading philosopher of the twentieth century, ON CERTAINTY is certain to be the one which you will understand the best, because it even tells you how you eventually understand something by finally stopping yourself from asking any more questions about it. As Wittgenstein's last book, close to being his dying words, it is something like a final opportunity for readers to surrender to Wittgenstein's power as a philosopher to keep thinking `I doubt it.'
After World War One, Wittgenstein attempted teaching at an elementary level in a few small Austrian farm villages. Wittgenstein came from a large family which employed an enormous number of tutors to provide its children with individual instruction. You could read Ray Monk's biography if you are interested in disputes about how many grand pianos were in Wittgenstein's house when he was growing up, and how many he said he had without implying that he could play them all at the same time, later on among Englishmen, who were capable of being impressed by numbers between one and ten, all of which might have been true at one point, if the Wittgensteins brought in a few extra grand pianos for some special occasion. ON CERTAINTY seems to be driven by the kind of attempt to produce intellectual slaves that was most recently attacked by the decision of the United States Supreme Court striking down the affirmative action program, which granted 20 points out of 150 possible points scored for undergraduate admission to the University of Michigan.
Even in free countries, law is expected to dominate in the intellectual slavery of free peoples, and judges, the majority of whom are white people dominated by the kind of logic that appeals to their interests, ultimately control the kind of decisions which can be made when the equality of the systems of the United States is directly challenged. Michigan is a state which is highly developed industrially and intellectually, with a large portion of black descendants of the kind of slaves who made the white masters of the south so financially successful in the years before the American Civil War. The affirmative action program at the University of Michigan was an attempt to make a large number of the black leaders in Michigan intellectual slaves of a tradition that is so inclusive that the normal political understanding of the politically astute slaves of mediocrity will not allow this kind of uppity boosting to take place. 20 points is outrageous, as a number to be used against the average white applicant, because it suggests a level of intellectual and social attainment that an average politically mediocre individual could never hope to attain.
ON CERTAINTY should be a perfect guide for understanding how the 20 point system works, because each individual's score was determined with the kind of mathematical precision that anyone with a brain like Wittgenstein's could only applaud, and any U.S. Supreme Court opinion to the contrary, hoping for some kind of individual evaluation which refuses to stick numbers on particular kinds of distinctions, while trying to achieve the same results, only more indistinctly, raises the possibility that for those who rule, everything is seemingly hidden from the ruled, in the kind of intellectual slavery that could be most aptly described as a secret circus stunt method of swaying vast multitudes, and which damns the state which would try to teach people to think any differently.
 |
Title: Philosophical Investigations: The German Text, With a Revised English Translation by Ludwig Wittgenstein, G. E. M. Anscombe, Elizabeth Anscombe ISBN: 0631231277 Publisher: Blackwell Publishers Pub. Date: 01 January, 2002 List Price(USD): $31.95 |
 |
Title: Blue & Brown Books by Ludwig Wittgenstein ISBN: 0061312118 Publisher: Perennial Pub. Date: 07 July, 1942 List Price(USD): $14.50 |
 |
Title: Tractatus Logico Philosophicus (Routledge Classics) by Ludwig Wittgenstein, David Francis Pears, Brian McGuinness, Bertrand Russell ISBN: 0415254086 Publisher: Routledge Pub. Date: 01 September, 2001 List Price(USD): $14.95 |
 |
Title: Wittgenstein Lectures and Conversations on Aesthetics, Psychology, and Religious Belief by Wittgenstein ISBN: 0520013549 Publisher: University of California Press Pub. Date: 01 June, 1967 List Price(USD): $13.95 |
 |
Title: Ludwig Wittgenstein: The Duty of Genius by Ray Monk ISBN: 0140159959 Publisher: Penguin Books Pub. Date: 01 November, 1991 List Price(USD): $21.00 |
Thank you for visiting www.AnyBook4Less.com and enjoy your savings!
Copyright� 2001-2021 Send your comments
